Watch The Hand You're Dealt

While Duke helps Audrey look into the mystery behind the Colorado Kid and who was present the morning the body was discovered, Nathan pulls Audrey into a new case, tracking down a killer on the loose in Haven. But when they track down the one person present at the scenes of each crime, their suspect turns the tables on them: she claims to have been trying, and failing, to save the lives of people whose deaths she had already foreseen.